insaneclownjoe's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Super Mario Bros. Underwater]

did you record this yourself?

The guy that wrote the original score is a very talented man. Hopefully we can all be as great as him someday.

BeatDarkX responds:

why u give a 5? XD

[The Outside World]

urgh...

Look, I'm not gonna give you a great score because you begged for one. This isn't your music. You just took a bunch of the loops from garageband and put them together. I make all of my music with garage band, and I record it all myself. You can do that! Hell, even if you don't have a midi keyboard, you can still use your computer's! Try recording your own work. I won't blam you because it sounds somewhat interesting. Seriously though.. Try making something completely original!

stickmaster1782 responds:

In other words, you want me to record somthing thats totally not my work from a radio. Yeah, i don't you should be talking. Your music is at 1.00 and lower.

[Mac8 - Emerging From Solitude]

very nice

not quite the saddest thing I've ever heard, but that doesn't stop it from being beautiful! Good Luck!

SinJim responds:

Yea, I'm not very good at making the saddest song ever, but I like to think it represents that in between feeling. Solitude and just not being satisfied, etc. I'm glad you liked it! Good luck to you too!

~SinJim

[:=>Passion<=:]

someone's a rebel...

It's not a bad song. And my oh my, that description! You're just a lone wolf aintcha?!

Moltov responds:

Lol thats none of yourbusiness ^^.

[(NUB)I would have hated myself]

oh my god....

Your intro did it in for me... I'm all tearing up! I know exactly what you're talking about and have been dealing with that. Listening to this song, I couldn't help but picture just the saddest things a child has to watch... This song has my vote so far...-sob-

nubbinownz responds:

thank you joe. your review means alot to me.

[- Feelings -]

A little upbeat...

Great work, but seems a little too driven to win as the saddest song on the block. Keep cuttin' away at it man!

Greeksta-69 responds:

I didnt create this to be the saddest beat on the block, i made it because this is how i was feeling at the time.

Thanks for your review.

[MAC8 - Memories [Final]]

I'm not gonna say it's shit,

But I'm not gonna say it's the best I've ever heard. Maybe it's just that i don't like listening to screeching and random moaning... Either way, Interesting song?

SuperMusic responds:

Haha - alright then. Keep in mind this is only a DEMO... you should check out the second version.

[Cayur - Achaia]

touching, but not quite sad...

Seems a bit too uplifting for me... The contest's goal is to capture pure sadness. This piece captures some, but then it builds from there. The length of the produces a story in itself. A beautiful piece nonetheless!

sculpted-cold responds:

There are a few mood swings, but I think it mostly captures sadness. Haha, it was originally eight minutes long, but I decided to cut out a section that I'm thinking about using for one of my next songs.

Thanks for listening!

[MAC8-Michael's Theme]

Reminds me a lot of FF7

Lucky for you, I LOVE that game. Hopefully in time I can get my piano playing skills up to what you're using. I dunno. It sounds wonderful!